Samurai or ninja. what would you choose.

Discuss historical events and information concerning any culture, time, or location in our world (or even the frontier beyond).

What would you choose to become.

Samurai
26
67%
Ninja
13
33%
 
Total votes : 39

Unread postby Kayzr » Thu Jan 04, 2007 8:23 pm

Samurai, of course!
Let us begin with Zeus, whom we mortals never leave unspoken.
For every street, every market-place is full of Zeus.
Even the sea and the harbour are full of this deity.
Everywhere everyone is indebted to Zeus.
For we are indeed his offspring.
Kayzr
Scholar of Shen Zhou
 
Posts: 1126
Joined: Wed Jan 05, 2005 10:27 pm
Location: Rome.

Unread postby Shikanosuke » Wed Jan 10, 2007 11:12 pm

Xiahou Jia wrote:I think it's time to bring some fun :wink:
It was not uncommon to be a Ninja AND a Samurai.
For example, Hattori Hanzo Iwami-no Kami Masanari, who was the son of the famous Hattori Hanzo, was deprived of the title of the samurai and lost the command over Iga-gumi after he provoked the Iga-gumi rebellion and killed the servant of Ina Kumazo Tadatsugu (the governor of 8 provinces of Kanto).

Anyway, it's not really correct to choose one OR another. Despite the popular myths spread by very influential people nowdays, there was never ever any confrontation between ninjas and samurai only because of their so called "hatred" to each other. Even Nobunaga's campaign against Iga ninjas was only against those ninjas who were not his or Ieyasu's allies. The Koga ninjas allied with Ieyasu and use him in diplomatic talks with Nobunaga . In the end Nobunaga agreed and kept his promise and didn't touch them. Tarao Sirobei Mitsuhiro and Hori Hidemasa (two ninjas from Koga) were taking an active part in destroying Iga. Nobunaga WAS using ninjas but to less extend than any other daymyo.

I have to disagree with the post that the methods found in Ninjutsu originated outside Japan. The basic ideas - yes, but the methods were mostly developed by Hattori Hanzo, Saika Magoichi, Momochi Sandayu and some others.


So who was a ninja and a samurai?

I don't think there is a myth of hatred between samurai and ninja per se, but rather a general hatred toward ninjas. Where as samurai was a respected class of the upper nobility, ninjas were often vagabonds employed to do certain steal, kill, or gather information missions. Wether or not they were trained in ninjitsu or not, from my understanding of japaneese history, one could still be considered a ninja. Often these men werent trained, rather simply possessing the abilities to navigate quickly through terrain to deliver messages or skilled enough to put a straight sword/knife (versus the katana's curved edge as they are for different purposes) through someones back.
User avatar
Shikanosuke
Scholar of Shen Zhou
 
Posts: 4307
Joined: Thu Nov 09, 2006 2:22 am
Location: US

Unread postby underoath8821 » Thu Jan 11, 2007 1:43 am

heh.. I would be samurai, but I would be currupt and use my skill for evil :twisted:
User avatar
underoath8821
Apprentice
 
Posts: 25
Joined: Sat Dec 30, 2006 1:07 am

Unread postby Pi Ka Chu » Thu Jan 11, 2007 2:26 am

I had rather do things in stealth, that way I won't have live with people knowing what I have done.
Nice guys don't insists on being creepers just because they were nice.
User avatar
Pi Ka Chu
Scholar of Shen Zhou
 
Posts: 738
Joined: Mon Jan 01, 2007 2:18 am
Location: Watching Ratatosk insult the eagle on Yggdrasil for the wrym Níðhöggr

Unread postby Xiahou Jia » Fri Jan 12, 2007 7:38 am

Shikanosuke wrote:
Xiahou Jia wrote:I think it's time to bring some fun :wink:
It was not uncommon to be a Ninja AND a Samurai.
For example, Hattori Hanzo Iwami-no Kami Masanari, who was the son of the famous Hattori Hanzo, was deprived of the title of the samurai and lost the command over Iga-gumi after he provoked the Iga-gumi rebellion and killed the servant of Ina Kumazo Tadatsugu (the governor of 8 provinces of Kanto).

Anyway, it's not really correct to choose one OR another. Despite the popular myths spread by very influential people nowdays, there was never ever any confrontation between ninjas and samurai only because of their so called "hatred" to each other. Even Nobunaga's campaign against Iga ninjas was only against those ninjas who were not his or Ieyasu's allies. The Koga ninjas allied with Ieyasu and use him in diplomatic talks with Nobunaga . In the end Nobunaga agreed and kept his promise and didn't touch them. Tarao Sirobei Mitsuhiro and Hori Hidemasa (two ninjas from Koga) were taking an active part in destroying Iga. Nobunaga WAS using ninjas but to less extend than any other daymyo.

I have to disagree with the post that the methods found in Ninjutsu originated outside Japan. The basic ideas - yes, but the methods were mostly developed by Hattori Hanzo, Saika Magoichi, Momochi Sandayu and some others.


So who was a ninja and a samurai?

I don't think there is a myth of hatred between samurai and ninja per se, but rather a general hatred toward ninjas. Where as samurai was a respected class of the upper nobility, ninjas were often vagabonds employed to do certain steal, kill, or gather information missions. Wether or not they were trained in ninjitsu or not, from my understanding of japaneese history, one could still be considered a ninja. Often these men werent trained, rather simply possessing the abilities to navigate quickly through terrain to deliver messages or skilled enough to put a straight sword/knife (versus the katana's curved edge as they are for different purposes) through someones back.


1. The most succesfull ninjas who were employed by Ieyasu Tokugawa were usually rewarded with the titles of samurai.
2. There was never found a single STRAIGHT ninja sword. Yes, they were short but it was Hollywood and "modern ninjas" who made them straight. The are only two museums in Japan that are historically accurate (the museum of Ninjutsu in Iga Ueno and ninja-yasiki in Konan) and there are NO STRAIGHT SWORDS there. Not a single one. The straight sword is just another popular myth.
Retired...
User avatar
Xiahou Jia
Scholar of Shen Zhou
 
Posts: 805
Joined: Tue Mar 07, 2006 1:10 pm

Unread postby Davey Vengeance » Fri Jan 12, 2007 11:20 am

I would have to choose the honourable life of a samurai over the hidden covert life of a ninja. In a time where honour was rewarded I'd rather be at war than sneaking around spying and stabbing people in the back. Also I am not exactly lightfooted so being a warrior would be an obvious choice. I think its far more honourable to face and enemy on the Battlefield than kill them in there sleep.
Forever X

Like Suikoden? Like RPing?
Then please come and join us at CASTLE NORTH WIND
Say Belcoot sent you...see you there. :)
User avatar
Davey Vengeance
Scholar of Darkness
 
Posts: 1814
Joined: Fri Sep 20, 2002 12:07 pm
Location: Huddersfield, UK

Unread postby SunXia » Fri Jan 12, 2007 11:24 am

I think it would be cool to be a ninja, and being really stealthy but like Davey, I'm very heavy-footed, (believe me I've been compared to a herd of Elephants in my time) so I guess I'd be a Samurai, if I was allowed to be of course!!
If becoming enlightened or an intellectual means I must become arrogant and coldly cynical about the world around me then I'd gladly remain a fool for the rest of my life!!

I'm Out4Marriage!!!Are You??

It is a CHOICE!!
User avatar
SunXia
Warrior Princess
Warrior Princess
 
Posts: 6523
Joined: Sun Jul 31, 2005 3:48 pm
Location: Keeping Evils from this world at bay...with a smile!!

Unread postby Davey Vengeance » Fri Jan 12, 2007 11:39 am

SunXia wrote:I think it would be cool to be a ninja, and being really stealthy but like Davey, I'm very heavy-footed, (believe me I've been compared to a herd of Elephants in my time) so I guess I'd be a Samurai, if I was allowed to be of course!!


Was there ever such a thing as a Lady Samurai? I mean the ninja's had Kunoichi but its another thing that Hollywood glorifies. I am sure there must have been some women capable with a sword though whether they used it on the field is beyond me.
Forever X

Like Suikoden? Like RPing?
Then please come and join us at CASTLE NORTH WIND
Say Belcoot sent you...see you there. :)
User avatar
Davey Vengeance
Scholar of Darkness
 
Posts: 1814
Joined: Fri Sep 20, 2002 12:07 pm
Location: Huddersfield, UK

Unread postby Tan_Binrui » Fri Jan 12, 2007 6:18 pm

Davey Vengeance wrote:Was there ever such a thing as a Lady Samurai? I mean the ninja's had Kunoichi but its another thing that Hollywood glorifies. I am sure there must have been some women capable with a sword though whether they used it on the field is beyond me.


Not that I know of. There have been female warriors, but I don't know of any who were officially samurai.
"Because he has died, there is no more room for death in him." -- Lao Tzu
User avatar
Tan_Binrui
Langzhong
 
Posts: 464
Joined: Fri Dec 08, 2006 6:42 am
Location: Orange County, CA

Unread postby Davey Vengeance » Fri Jan 12, 2007 6:26 pm

Tan_Binrui wrote:
Davey Vengeance wrote:Was there ever such a thing as a Lady Samurai? I mean the ninja's had Kunoichi but its another thing that Hollywood glorifies. I am sure there must have been some women capable with a sword though whether they used it on the field is beyond me.


Not that I know of. There have been female warriors, but I don't know of any who were officially samurai.


Thats what I thought, i assumed that all those years ago a womans place would not have been on the battle field.
Forever X

Like Suikoden? Like RPing?
Then please come and join us at CASTLE NORTH WIND
Say Belcoot sent you...see you there. :)
User avatar
Davey Vengeance
Scholar of Darkness
 
Posts: 1814
Joined: Fri Sep 20, 2002 12:07 pm
Location: Huddersfield, UK

PreviousNext

Return to World History Deliberation

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest

Copyright © 2002–2008 Kongming’s Archives. All Rights Reserved