Who do you like better: Xiahou Dun or Xiahou Yuan?

[1mandynasty]

i pefer both without them cao cao is nothing

[xiaoxiannu]

Dun...at least he is not get killed by enemy general in surprise attack

[Gongsun Idiot]

They were both capable generals.In my view, none is as fierce as Xiahou Dun (Come on,that guy ate his own eye and cleaved poor Cao Xings empty head).
But Xiahou Yuan was a master warrior in his own way (The second defeat of Ma Chao was not at last his credit and I like him for that)

[Zeche]

Better Fighter: Dun
Better General: Yuan
Better Tactician: Yuan
Better Politician: Dun
Better Overall: Dun

Who I like More: Dun

[PhoenixRising]

They were both capable generals.In my view, none is as fierce as Xiahou Dun (Come on,that guy ate his own eye and cleaved poor Cao Xings empty head).

Historically, he didn't eat his eyes.

Dun...at least he is not get killed by enemy general in surprise attack

but Dun was captured by a bandit ...i think it's better Xiahou Yuan in battle. For internal court affairs matter, Dun is better.

[xiaoxiannu]

but Dun was captured by a bandit ...i think it's better Xiahou Yuan in battle. For internal court affairs matter, Dun is better.

what ? when did it happen ? sgz version ?

[Dong Zhou]

Yep, that is the version Phoniex is referring to

[Tan_Binrui]

what ? when did it happen ? sgz version ?

It happened during the war between Cao Cao and Lu Bu, after Lu Bu captured Yan Province. Xiahou Dun was captured during the initial assault, and Han Hao got him out of his mess.