by CK on Tue Mar 04, 2003 4:09 am
To digress from the question but nevertheless quintessential. Perhaps one of the reason why Liu Biao, with such a huge area of land and extraordinary talents underneath, failed to be an awesome ruler because he was very much like Yuan Shao, all appearance no substance and too suspicious of other people.
As Chen Shou commented at the end of Liu Biao's biography in SGZ, "Yuan Shao and Liu Biao seemed like intimidating men who commanded respect with faily good reputations... however, even if they look generous on the outside, they are nonetheless overly suspicious; even if they enjoyed contributions in strategems, they lack the decisiveness to implement them; even if they had no lack of talents, none were relied and used upon; even if they recognised excellent suggestions, they would fail to implement it because of distrust. Both also abandoned tradition by giving in to personal desires and appointing the younger son as heir apparent. Eventually, their country was destroyed which was nothing to take pity of..."
Clearly, Liu Biao's suspicion can be seen in how he wanted to kill Han Song immediately when the latter proposed surrendering to Cao Cao. While Han Song had goodwill in his suggestion, Liu Biao thought Han had betrayed him.
Truth is always partial
Absense of dream creates nothing but dream creates absense if you do nothing