Wen Yang wrote:I have to say yes and no. Lu Meng could have used the same tactics he did against Guan Yu and had the same favorable results against Wei. So Guan Yu would have been able to defeat Cao Ren. But I am sure Lu Meng would just turn on Guan Yu after Wei was defeated though, so Guan Yu would probably have lost in the long run anyway.
Lord Zhuge wrote:I would say yes. He had almost already won, and would have done so, if he didn't have to go chase Lu Meng.
Zhou Gongjin wrote:He didn't chase Lu Meng at all, he came back to his headquarters, his forces deserted and he was killed in one last battle.
The order for Guan Yu to attack Fan seems rather dangerous to me, as it would not really help Shu at all to leave their flank open to Wu like that.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 4 guests
Copyright © 2002–2008 Kongming’s Archives. All Rights Reserved