rcsha wrote:Now Xu Shu was said to be stronger and a better warrior than Guo Jia. But that's because he was originally a swordsman and Guo Jia was always a scholar and a strategist.
Ender wrote:That's why I like Xu Shu. He was a warrior as well as a good, I said good not great, strategest. Its hard to tell who I would want more but I would probably rather have Guo Jia. He was a better strategest and like you said probably more loyal. Don't get me wrong I like Xu Shu to but would rather have Guo Jia.
In SGYY he goes to Cao Cao through deception but historically he joined Cao Mengde during battle.
Simfish wrote:May I ask where is the evidence of Xu Shu joining Cao Cao during battle?
(I've only read SGYY, and do not understand Chinese, so I cannot understand SGZ or other historical Chinese documents, sadly.)
Users browsing this forum: Bing [Bot] and 4 guests
Copyright © 2002–2008 Kongming’s Archives. All Rights Reserved