Page 1 of 20

Your five tiger generals of each kingdom

Unread postPosted: Wed Oct 30, 2002 12:13 pm
by Sam
Who would be your five tiger generals of each of the three kingdoms? Have the first one you choose at the top be the leader of the five generals of their kingdom, this is who I would choose:

Shu:
Jiang Wei
Huang Zhong
Guan Yu
Zheng Fei
Wei Yan

Wu:
Lu Meng
Gan Ning
Taishi Ci
Huang Gai
Zhou Tai

Wei:
Li Dian
Xu Huang
Zhang Liao
Pang De
Xiahou Dun

Unread postPosted: Wed Oct 30, 2002 1:06 pm
by Jimayo
Are we basing this on history or the novel?

Unread postPosted: Wed Oct 30, 2002 1:12 pm
by Zhang of Yen
I am not putting it from the rulers point of view

Shu
Wei Yan
Huang Zhong
Zhang Fei
Jiang Wei
Guan Yu

Wei
Cao Ren
Zhang Liao
Pang De
Cao Zhen
Xu Huang

Wu
Huan Gai
Cheng Pu
Lu Meng
Zhuge Jin
Taishi Ce

Unread postPosted: Wed Oct 30, 2002 1:51 pm
by Sam
It doesn't matter, just say if your going by the novel or by history in your post Jimayo.

Unread postPosted: Wed Oct 30, 2002 2:21 pm
by Jimayo
I'll do both then.

History
Shu
Wei Yan
Zhang Fei
Huang Zhong
Guan Yu
Li Yan

Wu
Lu Meng
Lu Xun
Lu Kang
Huang Gai
Gan Ning

Wei
Zhang Liao
Deng Ai
Xiahou Dun
Cao Ren
Zhang He

Novel
Shu
Guan Yu
Zhang Fei
Zhao Yun
Huang Zhong
Wei Yan

Wu
Lu Meng
Lu Xun
Huang Gai
Taishi Ci
Gan Ning

Wei
Zhang Liao
Deng Ai
Xiahou Yuan
Xu Huang
Xu Zhu

Unread postPosted: Wed Oct 30, 2002 4:35 pm
by Cao Zhi
I'll go by the novel.

Wei
Zhang Liao
Xu Huang
Pang De
Xiahou Dun
Zhang He

Wu
Taishi Ci
Huang Gai
Zhou Tai
Gan Ning
Cheng Pu

Shu
Guan Yu
Zhang Fei
Wei Yan
Huang Zhong
Zhou Yun

And just for fun, a little all star team from the three kingdoms :)

Zhang Fei
Pang De
Wei Yan
Taishi Ci
Zhang Liao

Unread postPosted: Wed Oct 30, 2002 4:40 pm
by Jimayo
Cao Zhi wrote:And just for fun, a little all star team from the three kingdoms :)

Zhang Fei
Pang De
Wei Yan
Taishi Ci
Zhang Liao


Personally I would of had Lu Meng or Huang Gai over Taishi Ci, and Zhang He or Xu Huang over Pang De(he really didn't do much, I'm not putting down his skill, but he's lacking in accomplishments).

Unread postPosted: Wed Oct 30, 2002 4:47 pm
by Cao Zhi
Jimayo Oyamitch wrote:
Cao Zhi wrote:And just for fun, a little all star team from the three kingdoms :)

Zhang Fei
Pang De
Wei Yan
Taishi Ci
Zhang Liao


Personally I would of had Lu Meng or Huang Gai over Taishi Ci, and Zhang He or Xu Huang over Pang De(he really didn't do much, I'm not putting down his skill, but he's lacking in accomplishments).


I actually considered Huang Gai over Taishi Ci for his extensive role, physical endurance, and strength at ChiBi. Pang De was a tossup with Xu Huang, but I though that Pang De, had he lived, might have shown a great amount of potential. I am not knocking Zhang He or Xu Huang (indeed, they were some of my favorite generals in the novel,) but I just felt that Pang De might have been the victor in a duel between either of them. I also considered Deng Ai for Wei.

Unread postPosted: Wed Oct 30, 2002 4:54 pm
by Han Xin
Shu:
Wei Yan
Guan Yu
Zhang Fei
Huang Zhong
Liu Feng

Wu:
Zhou Yu (founder of the Republic)
Lu Meng
Taishi Ci
Bu Zhi
Xu Sheng

Wei: No idea yet...

Unread postPosted: Wed Oct 30, 2002 4:56 pm
by Jimayo
Han Xin wrote:Zhou Yu (founder of the Republic)


Arguable