My all star Five would be:
Sun Ce (i no his a leader but who cares)
Lu Xun
Zhao Yun
Xiahou Dun
Zhang Liao
Andros wrote:Hello together,
I made my own TOP 5 Ranking of Wu Generals (in the period 208-222) , but I need some help for the last two free spots.
My Top 5 are:
Zhou Tai
Gan Ning
Ling Tong
???????
???????
You can choose two of these characters:
Ding Feng - killed Zhang Liao, but was only a subgeneral and his great time was later
Cheng Pu - yeah he was a great number, but after Nanjun he didn't fight
Lu Meng - correct me if I am wrong, but he was a strategist or did he really fight?
Zhu Ran - his great accomplishments took place after the mentioned time period. Or am I wrong about that?
Lu Xun - more a strategists???
Taishi Ci - Died in Hefei or rather before Chibi.
Xu Sheng - Was he a top general or did he beat a great general?
As I said above Chen Shou in his groupings normally didn't include CIC's like the two Lu's whilst I feel Ding Feng was too late.
Han wrote:As I said above Chen Shou in his groupings normally didn't include CIC's like the two Lu's whilst I feel Ding Feng was too late.
Are you talking about five tigers and five elites?
Guan Yu( Xu and Jing), Zhang Fei( HanZhong), Ma Chao(Xiliang), had complete command at some point in time during their long careers.
Zhang Liao also had autonomy shared with Yue Jin at Hefei.
Return to Sanguo Yanyi Symposium
Users browsing this forum: Bing [Bot] and 3 guests
Copyright © 2002–2008 Kongming’s Archives. All Rights Reserved